What if the stars aren’t trying to tell you what will happen, but are instead calling you back to something you’ve always known? There’s a question surfacing quietly among those who pay attention to these things: is astrology becoming a new kind of religion? Not in the old sense—not with cathedrals or creeds—but something softer, stranger, more personal. Something that gathers us not around dogma but around a shared sense that the cosmos has a psyche, and that psyche speaks through the symbols of our lives. You might have felt it yourself—that moment when a transit explains not just your mood but your entire history. That’s not prediction. That’s recognition.
Nechepso Astrology Software
Get 20% Off Nechepso when you use our link or enter code NIGHTLIGHT20 at checkout.
https://nla.to/NECHEPSO
✶ Learn Astrology With Me & Our Growing Community → https://nla.to/COURSES
In this episode, we walk through the seven dimensions that define a religion—ritual, myth, doctrine, community, ethics, experience, and material expression—and hold them up against modern astrology like a mirror. What we find is that astrology has always lived inside the world’s spiritual traditions, from the Vedas to the mystics. But today, as it gains popularity, something is shifting. The question isn’t whether astrology can be religious—it’s whether the way we practice it now is actually leading us toward reconnection, or just toward more information about ourselves. Because a chart without soul is just a map of the ego.
🤝 SHARE WITH A FRIEND ❣️: https://youtu.be/PrmuiVc3tgE
The rituals of astrology—the daily charts, the transit tracking, the watching of moons—can easily become habits of self-interest. But if they aren’t pointing you back toward the divine, toward the mystery that holds you, then they’re just data. A religion without the sacred is a club. Astrology without the soul is a weather report. The real question isn’t whether astrology is a religion—it’s whether you’re using it to remember what you are.
So pull up a chair. Let’s sit with the strange and beautiful possibility that the sky has always been speaking, and that maybe—just maybe—it’s been trying to lead you home all along. Whether astrology becomes a religion depends less on the stars and more on what you do with what you see.
————
GUILD MEMBERSHIP
An intimate circle of dedicated practitioners seeking fellowship, refinement, and inspiration within the lineage of Nightlight Astrology.
➜ https://nla.to/GUILD
2026 MASTER CLASS ON THE DECANS
The Oracle’s Tapestry is a four-part, twelve-class master series devoted to the 36 decans of the zodiac.
➜ https://nla.to/DECANS
ASTROLOGY RETREAT
The Oracle Within — A Training in the Theory and Practice of Divinatory Astrology. A Rare Immersion into the Living Wisdom of the Stars.
➜ https://nla.to/RETREAT
————
Subscribe to Nightlight Astrology Podcast on Apple
https://apple.co/4gI5UQz
Watch or listen on your favorite platform:
Transcript
Hey everyone. This is Adam Elenbaas from Nightlight Astrology [https://nightlightastrology.com/].
Happy Sunday, everyone.
I've got a bonus episode cooked up for you guys. Today we're going to ask the question of whether or not astrology should be considered a new religion. Seems like a strange question on the surface, but I've been noticing this question coming up a lot, and I was actually asked to write an article on this question for an astrological magazine later this year. My written version of this talk will actually appear in a magazine.
And the reason for that is that whenever Saturn and Neptune get together in conjunction, years like this, there's a long history of astrologers noticing that major changes happen, either within the trajectory of existing religions, or often new religions or religious or spiritual groups or communities are formed, even within the field of astrology. For example, the Saturn Neptune conjunction that coincided around the same time that Uranus was also in the mix in Capricorn, the late 80s, early 90s, coincided with the emergence of Hellenistic astrology, which is kind of a new sect of astrology. So within the spiritual field of astrology, a new sect emerges, one that's rooted in the appearance of new doctrines and teachings from a lost era, so to speak. So it's a thing.
But the question we might ask ourselves right now, especially considering the increasing amount of money that's being put into the astrological industry, astrological software programs, the marriage of AI in astrology, which is concerning, obviously, but also just the prevalence of astrologers. I remember when my wife and I opened a yoga studio back in 2011, and you know, between now and then, the prevalence of yoga studios and yoga teachers has, you know, sort of exploded. We're seeing something similar in the astrological industry. It's a lot more common for people to be an astrologer, to see an astrologer, to be aware of astrological transits, to be aware of Mercury retrogrades or eclipses, for example.
And so it might be worth asking ourselves, look, is astrology becoming a new religion itself right now? I mean, for a lot of us, it's been around for a long time, so we're like, well, not for me, it's not. It might have played that role for you for a very long time, but is it more popularly becoming a new religion right now? So I'm going to address that question today, and I will give you a reason why we might say yes, and I'm going to give you a reason why we might say no, and I'll tell you what I think about it as well, but hopefully give you enough ideas and thoughts to make a decision for yourself.
Anyway, before we get into it, remember to like and subscribe. If you get something out of this channel, throw a quarter in the hat by giving us the subscribe or the like or a comment. It really helps the algorithm find us, and then we can keep growing and thriving in what we do, in the way that we serve you guys with this content. You can find transcripts of any of these daily talks on my website, which is nightlightastrology.com. No promotions for the day, because it's a bonus episode. We're just going to get straight into it.
Look. When I was in my undergraduate program in philosophy, I was at a religious school at the time. I thought I was going to become a pastor. I guess I do. I've always joked that I give sermons from the stars. And I was a preacher's kid, so maybe I've still taken up something. I don't know, kind of a clergy of some kind, God knows of what. But anyway, when I was in my undergrad at a religious school, I was studying philosophy and world religion, interfaith studies, all very interesting to me, and I read a book that I had to pull off the shelf and look some details up from for this talk. It's called *Dimensions of Religion* by a gentleman named Ninian Smart, and it is widely taught in religious studies programs. I don't know if it still is or not. Maybe it's totally dated at this point, but anyway, it was something I had to become familiar with in my own studies.
And he gives seven very famous dimensions of what constitute a religion. If you know, a religion is a religion because it contains these seven dimensions. So what I'm going to do for you today is I'm going to go through these seven dimensions of religion, from Ninian Smart, and tell you first why I think astrology actually fills out every single dimension. And so, yeah, maybe we could say it's a religion. And maybe even more than that, we could say that it's becoming something like a religion. It's becoming a kind of spiritual sect, maybe not as institutional and defined as like a Protestant sect or the Catholic Church or something like that.
But I think there's an argument to be made, a case to be made, that we fill out all seven of these dimensions, and that the rise in growth and popularity and recognition of these seven dimensions among more and more people do indeed make it at least to be considered as a kind of new religion, and maybe one that we'll see grow from this point forward. Then I'm going to introduce some reasons why I think we might not be so quick to call this a new religion for a variety of reasons. And then I'll let you decide for yourself. I'll tell you kind of where I land at the end. But anyway, let's get into it.
So here's the seven dimensions that he mentions. The first one is ritual or practical. This would be things like ceremonies and prayers, liturgy, sacraments, meditation, etc. So is there a ritual and practical dimension to astrology? And I would say that there is. That ritual or practical dimension is as simple as the daily casting of charts, the casting of the birth chart, the casting of elections, the casting of horary charts for different purposes, often connected to different spiritual intentions, prayers, offerings to the gods. For 1000s of years, it's been this way.
But speaking more recently to our modern moment right now, because, by the way, astrology has been connected to world religions for 1000s of years. So in a way, this is kind of a silly question, because astrology has always been connected to religion, right? But in terms of, is it now for us, right now, becoming more of a popular modern, new religion? Well, does it satisfy all of these dimensions? Ritual and practical? Do we have practices that are repeatable and observed by many people for spiritual purposes? Yes, simple casting of charts, but also the creation of daily forecasting content, the tracking of history through transits and transit tracking and mundane forecasts. So yeah, I think there's a ritual and practical dimension that's satisfied.
Two, this is where it gets a little bit more subjective. Is there an experiential and emotional component? In other words, do people experience? Is there a personal, religious, experiential dimension to the practice of astrology? Are there mystical states? Do people convert somehow to astrology? Is there a sense of revelation connected? Now, again, this is a little subjective, but I would say certainly there is. For example, many, many, many people, 1000s that have come through our programs at Nightlight, over 16 years of professional practice, have said that they get bit by the astrological bug, which usually means they have an experience that they come to recognize, one way or another, as astrological.
They recognize their experiences, the insights or the meaning of an experience, in terms of the symbols of astrology, and they experience something like a conversion to an animate, mystical astrological cosmos, which they suddenly are peeking through the veil and understanding is real and present. And many people, like a spiritual conversion, are forever changed. And this may actually open the door to traditional or conventional religious participation as well. So and beyond that, our daily tracking of transits, our daily relationship to moon cycles or eclipses, our daily tracking and charting of the grab stories that we've done on this channel in the past, or the way that funny symbolism shows up under a Mercury retrograde and we go, that's the astrology. There's the astrology. You can't make this stuff up.
And the way that we often find ourselves in the midst of a deeply meaningful experience in life because the symbolism is speaking in the midst of it. I can't say that that is not experiential and emotional. On the one hand, it might just look like data tracking or transit and pattern tracking, but for anyone who lives astrology, you know that it's experiential and emotional to its core, and you can probably also relate to the idea that there are something like astrological conversion stories. I've seen way too many of them, way too frequently throughout my full career to say otherwise.
Number three, he says that the third dimension is called narrative and mythic. This would be sacred stories that explain things, that explain why things are the way that they are, origins, divine beings, cosmic order. Do we have something like that in astrology? Absolutely. Now, do we have a clear singular mono-myth about the creation of the universe? No, but we have an astrological model that was embedded in the cultures and tradition of many different religions dating back 1000s of years. That is the Heavenly Spheres model, which puts the Earth at the center and sees everything moving outward in concentric spheres that are like different dimensions of reality that the gods and goddesses preside over. And that semantic, symbolic model of reality, archetypal, often Platonic, Pythagorean, Vedic, pervades the modern imagination of astrology, of astrologers, just as much as it did people 1000s of years ago.
And our entire language is built off from gods, goddesses, myths, archetypes, ancient philosophy. So I think it's safe to say there is a strong narrative and mythic dimension, not only to the history of our field, but the way we talk about it on a day-to-day basis.
So number four is doctrinal and philosophical. Are there formal teachings or theological systems? Now, here's where it gets a little bit more controversial, because there are actually many different schools of astrology throughout the whole history of astrology. Are there doctrines of Hellenistic astrology? Absolutely. But are there doctrines of Vedic astrology that differ at times? Yeah, totally. Are there different doctrines of horary astrology, medical astrology? Yeah. Are there different philosophical emphases placed on the nodes from ancient Vedic to modern evolutionary astrology? Sure.
So rather than there being one set of formal teachings or one theological system, there's a plurality of them, but they often overlap. They often share more than they differ, and they often say very similar things about the nature of the soul, transmigration of the soul, the process of spiritual evolution, and it's been like that for 1000s of years. But I'd say most modern astrologers have a lot more in common in terms of doctrines of craft and philosophy, than they have like wild irreconcilable differences. I think this means we have something of a doctrinal and philosophical cohesion to our field. Now, again, that's just me really just sitting here and telling you what I think about it.
Right, number five, ethical and legal. Are there moral rules or laws governing behavior? I think this is even dicier, because, honestly, this might be the part that is most lacking in modern astrology. Now there are ethical guidelines present at Nightlight for our students. We talk about ethics of how to read for people, what kind of caring posture to assume for another soul in counseling. But there aren't strict, ethical and consistent ethical or legal guidelines all across the field that govern the behavior of astrologers. In fact, some of the most legitimate criticism of the field of astrology is that practitioners can often be so individualistic that they're not held to any kind of ethical or institutional standard when it comes to ethics.
So this is a bit of a gray area, but I would say if you go to OPA, if you go to NORWAC, if you go to UAC, if you go to major most of the major organizations, ISAR being another great example, NCGR, there's so many, and I'm probably forgetting some off the top of my head, the institutions that typically carry the most clout in the field or industry of astrology have strong ethical considerations baked into their constitutions or their organizations. So let's say, broadly speaking, that it applies. Yeah, there are ethical and legal concerns. But one of the reasons that makes this complicated is that astrology is not so unified, and there are not a lot of governing institutions that set parameters or guidelines for practitioner behavior or certification, things like that. And so the oversight, the sense of oversight.
But I will add, just to be fair, that you know, if a religion is only defined by its ability to uphold or have ethical and legal standards that are consistent, then we really don't have many, because most of our world religions have very deep ethical and legal inconsistencies, just being honest, not trying to call anyone out or anything.
Now, social and institutional. Are there communities? Are there clergy? Are there authority structures and traditions? All of this is pretty loose, again, like the ethical and legal or doctrinal and philosophical, astrology is not an institution, not exactly. There are some institutions. Nightlight Astrology as a school is a kind of institution, but it's practitioner centric. A lot of modern astrology still works in the way that traditional apprenticeship models of learning worked. You apprentice with this local blacksmith and become a blacksmith through entrainment to their methods and their training. There's a lot of that in modern astrology. Steven Forrest has his own school, Nightlight Astrology is our own school. We have our own standards, and good schools will uphold those and stay pretty consistent to them. I'm always evolving, but we hold a standard that often allows people, if they follow the model and the curriculum, to be successful.
But are there clear hierarchies, delineated traditions of clergy, authority, structures, traditions? No. And that's another problem, is that kind of anyone can call themselves an astrologer. Now, the more that you start participating in group and community, the more that there is a kind of invisible accountability, because you start seeing who has integrity and who's serious and who's practicing and who's really getting good feedback, and who's developing other astrologers and who's giving back to the community. And so there's a way in which we do have a very strong community in modern astrology that clearly holds out examples of elders and people who have set the bar high, ethically, spiritually, craft wise.
There is tradition in terms of the things that we tend to do as astrologers together, the types of programs that we attend together. And so I would say it's looser than modern religious institutions, but there is a social institutional dimension. So again, I think we can safely say that there's enough of that there to be considered to satisfy this dimension of religion.
And then finally, is material. This would be physical expressions such as temples, art, relics, symbols. Well, the history of astrology is replete with astrological icons in temples, in artwork, in sacred relics and in symbols. Astrological symbolism permeates world religion, not just Hellenistic astrology or horoscopic astrology, but many different kinds of world celestial omen practices and astrology itself in a broader sense. So I think our planet actually has a really rich material history of astrology and religion together.
But in terms of our modern practice, do we have physical expressions? Well, and I know this might be a stretch, but think of how common it is to see people with zodiacal tattoos. Think of how common it is to see nowadays people's social media profiles or the way that advertising is driven toward different kinds of consumers in the marketplace based on their interest in things like yoga and astrology as an overlap of Eastern spirituality, new age mysticism. So is there a sense of art, aesthetics tied to astrology? I think there is. It's a little bit more Neptunian. It's a bit more like located in the zeitgeist somewhere. But yes, now in a digital age, are there temples? Yeah, they're called YouTube channels. In a weird way, I consider my YouTube channel a kind of temple, a temple for people who want spiritual practice of astrology every day. But play with these categories if you want to on your own and see what answer you come up with.
Now, here is my biggest concern. So on the one hand, being someone who is always open to sort of both sides of things, I find that maybe my Mars in Gemini is a bit like that. There's one part of me that has no problem saying yes. The part of me that hesitates is the part that goes, is this a new religion? The part of me that struggles is really not the idea that astrology can't be considered religious, that it doesn't. It clearly, not just now, but for 1000s of years. You know, I'm getting serious because I picked up a marker, I don't know why, but all of these dimensions that I'm listing here are not only satisfied right now, but have been, and even more strongly, for 1000s of years, and have been present in ancient Judaism, in ancient Christianity, more so ancient than recent. There's versions of astrology present in Buddhism, certainly the entire history of Vedic religious traditions and sects in India is permeated with this astrology. And that's not it. There's Stoics, there's Hermeticists, there's Platonists, there's Pythagoreans, there's Egyptian mystics. In the ancient world, there's no question in my mind whatsoever that astrology is inseparable from the fabric of many world religions and world religious traditions. But is it a new religion?
It's becoming more popular. But here's what I worry about. The word religion, from the Latin, the breakdown of the word is *religio*, which means something like to reconnect. The word religion shares the same basic etymological idea or image of reconnection that the word yoga does with yoking or uniting two things that are separate and putting them together into something that's whole. As far as I can tell, and I've done a lot of study of comparative ancient Eastern and Western religions, certainly all those that carried astrology as the earliest progenitors, they share an idea, which is that when we live in illusion and ignorance, we are in a disconnected and separated state of consciousness. We become separated from our divine nature.
Our divine nature means that we are a part of that which is sacred, eternal. You could call it God or Goddess, Higher Self, the Tao, oneness. And that when we live covered up and unaware of our true nature, that that is fundamentally connected to suffering and illusion. And it is ignorance. It is the definition of ignorance. I don't say this as someone who's not myself covered in ignorance, by the way. However, when we reconnect the world to its sacred wholeness, when we can reconnect ourselves right to the eternal, the divine, we relink and reconnect.
So here's my problem. There's a lot of the dimensions of astrology in these seven dimensions of religion that are currently satisfied in our modern era. I'm not sure the religion part is. All these dimensions of religion don't mean much if the ultimate goal isn't to relink the spirit or soul to the divine. And while we might have rituals and practices, if their only aim is selfish interest, like, what's going to happen to me? What do I get out of this? How do I get what do I want? How do I avoid what I don't want? Then it's not religious in nature, even though it fulfills a dimension of religion.
If it's experiential and emotional, it makes us feel like we live in a magical, synchronistic universe, but that doesn't also lead us then to transformation of consciousness that relinks self to divinity. Then it's just a high. It's no better, in a way, than having a mystical high through a psychedelic experience that has no greater context that awakens the soul.
Narrative and mythic dimensions might be fulfilled, but if they're anything more than metaphors that are being used to interpret things for selfish reasons, reasons that are not connected to the larger project of reconnecting soul to soul and spirit to divinity, then it doesn't matter.
Doctrinal and philosophical roots of the tradition, if they're only about craft and not about theology, if the craft isn't pointing us toward divinity, then what good is it? It's not really religious, in that sense.
Ethical and legal? Well, it's good to be good. But even as the yogis tell us, karma yoga on its own is not enough. In other words, just doing good stuff, doing good deeds or being an ethical person, is not enough if it's not also facilitating a transformation of consciousness. A lot of us mistake being good for being spiritual.
Social or institutional? Well, there's social or institutional presence to astrology, but if it's nothing more than craft and professional conferences, and it's not meant to direct the soul back to divinity and help us walk each other home, so to speak, then it's just another institution, however more dispersive and vague it may be.
And finally, material. If there's a level of aesthetic or art or artifact, but those artifacts, that collection of material artifacts, is not seen as evidence of divinity, if they're not pointing us towards some sacred ground that we all participate in and stand on, then it's just stuff.
Now here's the thing, all of this makes me very hesitant, based on what I see in the world of modern astrology, to call this a new religion, because I don't see masses of people suddenly awakening to the benefits of spiritual practice and self-care. I don't see a lot of astrologers, frankly, talking about why we're doing this, because it's meant to help our spirit and soul evolve and awaken divinity within our hearts. Now I'm not saying nobody does. I think there's a fair amount of practitioners that do, and those are obviously my favorites. I won't name names here because I'm not trying to gatekeep. I'm just telling the truth as I see it.
But here's the other thing. The problem is that you could apply the same criticism to any thing that calls itself a religion that fulfills the same exact things, but has core issues with materialism alive and awake and well within its fold. Christianity struggles from fulfilling these dimensions, but at times in certain communities and the hearts of individual practitioners, being nothing more than a country club for people who want to belong to the same moral and social fabric. And I'm not trying to be a jerk. It's just, in other words, it's sort of unfair to have an impossibly high standard when the same criticism could be applied to any current group or community that calls itself a religion that no one would think twice to ask whether it was a religion or not.
So that's where I land on all of this. I'm hesitant to call it a new religion, both because it's very ancient, has participated in many different world religions, is not so narrow that it can only be wed to one particular religious path. But at the same time, much of its modern expression lacks the basic definition of a religion as something meant to relink the soul to divinity. That it's aiming us toward that is weirdly absent from a lot of modern astrology, in my opinion.
But at the same time, it's sort of unfair to hold it to a standard when I think channels like myself and many other people out there, certainly like my, I think of all of my heroes in astrology that see astrology as this sacred, spiritual thing. But there's also, like, a lot of hype. You know, the same thing happens to yoga. Yoga comes to the West, mostly through asana, devoid of the vast matrix of Vedic rituals and temple practice. And I mean, really, asana is just like a tiny little part of what yoga is. And yet, in the West, we think of it as this whole spiritual thing unto itself. Well, it's not new for aspects of long-standing things to also be taken and sort of distorted, or, you know, to emerge as their own thing.
And a lot of people also treat yoga as nothing more than, you know, relaxation, which is good, stress relief, which is good. But they don't necessarily see yoga as a part of the overall Vedic project of reconnecting the soul to God. You know, that's not why they're going to a yoga class or a hot yoga class or whatever. So does that make it bad? No, not really. But can you then authentically call modern studio yoga a new religion? I don't know. And the same kind of thing troubles me around calling astrology a new religion. I think we need to be just thoughtful around such conversations.
And the final thing that comes to my mind is that the Taoist tradition says the way that can be named is not the way. And isn't it always the case that as soon as we start saying, hey, those teachings of Jesus were pretty great, let's institutionalize it and call it Christianity, the way that can be named is not the way. If we are seeing astrology becoming a new religion, then between you and me, I think we should keep it a secret.
All right, so that's what I've got for you today. Take it easy. Bye.





Leave a Reply